Schedule Appointment

Music Feedback

Thanks for considering giving me feedback on my music!  There’s a link to it at the bottom of the page, but first a note on what I’m looking for.

I have had some incredible feedback on my music so far, that has pointed out precisely what is compromising it and what could improve it, and has done so in a way that is encouraging and tangible enough to actually use as a basis for improvement or investigation. First it was about register (my first tracks were a mess of colliding parts), then rhythm and synchopation and more.  As a result, I’ve become much better at implementing these (and still improving).

So, I’m not just looking for any sort of random feedback, but specifically to find out my biggest current blind-spots that weaken my music.  What aspect most gives away that I’m a beginner with barely any music theory, and, most importantly, any pointers to help me to do so.

Through this and other ways, I will pick up more music theory, but doing this through a formal, structured approach with abstract learning and numerous compositional exercises will not work for me, even if they have a great logic behind them and may be ideal for others, due to how my brain works.   My learning preferences might also be different as an autistic person from those of a non-autistic person.

I realise, of course, that when I put my music out there and ask for feedback, I don’t get to compel anyone to respond in any particular way, but I do get to request what I want and hope that most people respect this. So this is my request:

Please DO respond if:

– You feel there is potential in the music and the composer and you feel you can point out/suggest something that can help realise more of that potential.
– You respect my approach of starting to compose music according to my learning preferences and without much knowledge of music theory as valid and do not see it as an automatically suboptimal approach.

Please DO NOT respond if you do not resonate with both of the statements above. I’m sure you have very insightful and expert thoughts, but they’re not likely to be useful to me in my particular case, and are more likely to dishearten and demotivate (just speaking from experience). In this case, not sharing will have a more positive result than sharing – which is, of course, no reflection on your expertise, experience or the validity of your insights. I’m not looking for a debate on whether my approach is valid or not – only feedback that I will be able to make practical use of.